top of page
Search

The Better Way to Get Divorced: Mediation vs. Litigation

Writer: John NachlingerJohn Nachlinger

Man and woman attending divorce mediation.
Man and woman attending divorce mediation.

If you're considering divorce, you might assume that hiring an attorney and heading straight to court is the only option. However, this traditional path is not always necessary, and in many cases, there’s a far better way to get divorced—mediation.


Understanding Mediation

Mediation is a process where a neutral third party, preferably an attorney experienced in divorce law, helps couples reach an agreement on all the key issues. This process allows both parties to discuss matters such as parenting schedules, asset division, and financial responsibilities in a structured and guided manner.


One of the biggest misconceptions about mediation is that attorneys must be involved in order for it to be effective. This is simply not true. Many couples enter mediation without attorneys, often after having informal discussions about their divorce and key concerns. If you and your spouse have W-2 jobs, share financial transparency, and have children but are not in a fierce custody battle, mediation is often the best solution for you.

The Cost of Litigation vs. Mediation

Many people are shocked to discover that they can sit down with a mediator and reach a full agreement in just a few hours. The idea that divorce has to be expensive, contentious, and drawn out is outdated and often incorrect. Instead of paying attorneys anywhere from $5,000 to $10,000 or more in retainers, many divorcing couples resolve all their issues through mediation for a fraction of the cost.


The alternative—litigation—can become incredibly expensive. A common saying in the legal world is that you can either put your kids through college or put your attorney’s kids through college. While this may be an exaggeration, it highlights the reality that litigation often leads to unnecessary financial strain. In litigation, attorneys must follow procedural requirements, which can slow down the process and lead to significant legal fees.


Mediation Requires Mutual Commitment

For mediation to work, both spouses must be committed to the process. If only one party is open to mediation while the other insists on going to court, the process may stall. Some individuals fear that mediation might not secure them what they are “entitled” to, or they worry that a controlling spouse will dominate the conversation. However, a skilled mediator ensures that both voices are heard and that fairness is maintained.


It is also possible to consult with an attorney for a single session before mediation to get legal advice on what you should ask for. This can provide peace of mind and ensure that you enter mediation with clarity and confidence.


Mediation Works for Most People

While mediation is an excellent option for many divorcing couples, it is not suitable for every situation. Cases involving domestic violence, significant financial complexity, or an uncooperative spouse may require litigation. However, for the vast majority—roughly 80% of couples—mediation is the simplest and most effective solution. If you and your spouse have shared financial transparency, similar expectations regarding parenting, and a willingness to negotiate fairly, mediation can save you time, stress, and thousands of dollars.


The Efficiency of Mediation

Most couples who go through mediation are surprised at how much they already agree on. A significant percentage of cases are resolved in just three-hour mediation sessions. The process fosters constructive dialogue and momentum, making it easier to compromise on smaller issues once major agreements have been reached. Instead of focusing on “winning” a divorce case, couples in mediation concentrate on fairness, practicality, and moving forward with their lives.


The Pitfalls of Traditional Divorce Litigation

Attorneys in litigation often insist on gathering excessive documentation, conducting extensive financial disclosures, and exchanging legal motions before reaching negotiations. While this is necessary in certain complex cases, for many couples, it’s an unnecessary expense and delay. If both parties already have access to financial records and agree on general terms, mediation is a straightforward alternative that bypasses much of the costly and time-consuming legal work required in litigation.


Many people are unaware of the mediation option simply because the traditional legal system is structured to encourage attorney involvement. Attorneys naturally want to ensure they have all the information before advising their clients, which leads to more extensive (and expensive) legal work. However, for couples with clear financials and a willingness to negotiate, these legal formalities are often unnecessary.


When Mediation Might Not Be Ideal

While mediation is a fantastic solution for many, it is not recommended in cases involving domestic violence, complex business ownership, or hidden financial assets. If one spouse is self-employed or there is significant uncertainty about financial matters, litigation might be necessary to ensure a fair outcome. However, these cases represent a small minority—most divorcing couples do not require such extensive legal intervention.


The Importance of Simplicity

Divorce is often made more complicated than it needs to be. The more complex the process, the more expensive it becomes. Keeping things simple and focusing on fair and efficient resolutions can significantly reduce stress and costs. Many people enter litigation hoping to receive what they believe they are “entitled” to, but the reality is that divorce settlements are rarely black and white. Factors such as alimony, child custody, and asset division involve nuanced considerations rather than strict legal entitlements.


The True Cost of Divorce

The average cost of a litigated divorce in the U.S. is around $15,000 to $16,000 per spouse. That means a typical couple might spend over $30,000 to finalize their divorce. This is a staggering figure compared to the cost of mediation, which is often completed for a fraction of the price. Despite advancements in virtual legal processes post-COVID, litigation remains costly and time-consuming.


Choosing the Right Mediator

Mediators are widely available, but not all are equally qualified. While some individuals advertise themselves as mediators without legal expertise, it is crucial to select someone familiar with divorce law. A skilled attorney-mediator ensures that all necessary topics—such as parenting schedules, property division, and financial considerations—are thoroughly discussed and resolved.


Some mediators come from mental health backgrounds, which can be beneficial for handling parenting disputes. Others, such as financial experts, may be useful in complex asset divisions. However, for most couples, an attorney-mediator is the best option to ensure a comprehensive and legally sound divorce settlement.


The Bottom Line: Mediation Saves Time, Money, and Stress

If you and your spouse are considering divorce, don’t automatically assume litigation is your only path. Sit down and have an honest conversation about mediation. Even if your relationship is strained, prioritizing efficiency and financial savings can lead to a smoother transition for both parties.


The longer a divorce drags on, the more expensive and stressful it becomes. By choosing mediation, you can avoid unnecessary conflict, preserve your financial resources, and move forward with your life more quickly and amicably. Give mediation a chance—it may be the best decision you make during this difficult time.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page